NVU joint faculty assembly unanimously votes No Confidence in Chancellor Spaulding
Just after 5:30 p.m. on Saturday, April 18, an unofficial joint NVU faculty assembly of over 50 members from both campuses unanimously voted “No Confidence” in VSCS Chancellor Jeb Spaulding. The vote came less than 48 hours after Spaulding’s original announcement that he would recommend the VSCS Board of Trustees close both campuses of NVU and the Randolph campus of VTC.
Also at the meeting were a couple of staff members and two student journalists, one from each campus of NVU.
At the beginning of the meeting at 5:00, Meaghan Meachem, the representative for the Lyndon Alumni Council and associate professor of digital and broadcast journalism, announced that the LAC had officially voted no confidence in Jeb and the Trustees in two separate votes in the same meeting. After the JAC vote, said representative Lauren Philie, the joint Alumni Council would release a letter which articulated the vote of No Confidence.
You can read the letter from the Joint Alumni Council here.
“We believe,” said Meachem, referring to the LAC, “that Jeb [Spaulding]’s actions are being driven by the Board of Trustees.”
Daniel Daley, faculty assembly chair for Lyndon, motioned that the vote be taken sooner rather than later, so that the release could get out that same night. While a normal meeting might require 48 hours’ notice, the quorum of both Lyndon and Johnson faculty decided against the warning, citing little time to get the release out.
Johnson Faculty Assembly Chair Tyrone Shaw noted that Castleton and VTC would also be taking a vote of no confidence in Spaulding and the Board.
“If we vote no confidence,” asked Barclay Tucker, “what does that really do?”
“It would get the board to appreciate the level of dismay engendered through the state,” replied Shaw.
Several professors asked that the motion be limited to a vote against Spaulding, excluding the Board, which was accepted. The meeting also agreed that the language in the press release would be written by the Executive Committees, which met after the initial meeting.
Another proposal by a professor was a motion to delay classes or reduce their academic load this week, to give students a break. Shaw agreed, and suggested that professors give as much leniency as possible to students who might be in, as another put it, “crisis mode.”
The letter, as worded by the Executive Committee, was sent to the Board of Trustees at 11:00 that night. It cites, among other things, the Chancellor Spaulding has “regularly not fulfilled his responsibilities to serve the students of the Vermont State Colleges System or the people of Vermont.”
“He has repeatedly made decisions without adequate consultation or a thorough analysis of
complete data,” the letter goes on to say. “He has consistently made recommendations without thoughtful consideration of the longterm consequences.”
“Given these egregious violations of the Vermont State Colleges System’s core mission,” it reads, “the
Faculty Assemblies of Northern Vermont University vote no confidence in Chancellor Jeb Spaulding.”
The letter is signed by Daley and Shaw. You can read the letter in full below.
Senior, Journalism & Creative Writing
Grew up in Atkinson, NH
Fall 2018
Along with traditional journalism, I enjoy writing satire and fun feature...
Ed Shanks • Apr 20, 2020 at 2:02 pm
I grew up on Vail Hill. As a kid saw the Vail building torn down and wondered Why? The college is one of the few economic engines left in the NEK. This announcement will hurt the college even further as kids looking for colleges are scared away because of it. When this pandemic ends I expect to see Vermont’s population to contract even further. It makes sense for people to look for economic opportunity in states with better Infrastructures and costs of living. Hopefully the legislature will begin to look at Vermont as a whole rather then just taking care of a few communities in the central and western parts of it.
Margaret T. Lipscomb • Apr 20, 2020 at 11:24 am
When young people leave their home state for college, either by choice or by need, most don’t come back. I raised three children in New York State, where the state colleges are similarly poorly supported by the state legislature and have high tuition. After high school, they all left for another state, lived there for the required period, and entered college as an in-state resident very cheaply. (For a community college it was usually only a six-month wait.) After getting their degree(s), none ever returned to New York State. One settled in Vermont and is raising two children. You aren’t going to get a younger Vermont population by closing colleges.
Keith Gordon • Apr 20, 2020 at 1:48 am
I sit in my living room and scratch my head because someone that touts “Vermont College’s prepare our Children for Real Life Situations”, is now ready to essentially Boot them out the Door! Who cares if they can’t get a job, or Finish their Educations, or Payback Their Loans! They will no doubt have to go to a College Outside of our fine State. And collect MORE DEBT. So much for keeping them Instate. You know, I bet if some of the people at the top of the Food Chain got their Jobs Cut, they would Scream, and Stop Their Feet, and say “It’s NOT Fair”! Jeb, as my Father used to say, “Don’t Cut You’re Nose Off to Spite You’re Face”! Figure it out!
H. Brooke Paige • Apr 19, 2020 at 5:21 pm
“There is NOTHING worse Yet Another Titanic Problem in the Vermont Sea of Troubles
There is nothing worse than a Captain who starts screaming “ABANDON SHIP” at the first sight of an iceberg on the horizon !
For Heaven’s Sake, $10M is just pocket change compared to the gazillion dollars the State hands over to UVM. Vermont State Colleges educates 9,506 in-state students compared to The University of Vermont which educates just 4,012 in-state students (At just 31% in-state attendance, UVM has-the smallest percentage of in-state students of any state funded college – nationwide).
While the political elite from Chittenden Co. only care about their local gem, the rest of the Vermonters are equally concerned about the future of the State Colleges that serve the other 90% of the state !
Time to let the folks at UVM ask their fancy Dan out-of-state students to start paying for their on ride !
Diane M. Cecere • Apr 19, 2020 at 3:45 pm
To Whom it May Concern,
I am a lifelong resident of Vermont, a retired public school Art Educator, and a very proud Mom of a Lyndon State College graduate. My son, Evan Coughlin, Class of 2011 has worked in his chosen field of Television News Broadcasting since completing his degree at LSC. We felt very fortunate that he was able to receive this caliber of his superb education within his home state, and at tuition costs that were affordable. We are devastated for current students, and future students who may lose this opportunity. Therefore, I vote “No Confidence” in Jeb Spaulding in his role as Chancellor. Please remove him immediately from this position, and find new leadership in someone who can work to strengthen and sustain these fine educational institutions in our beloved State of Vermont.
Signed,
Diane M. Cecere
Putney, VT
Rebecca Flieder • Apr 19, 2020 at 4:38 pm
Please make sure you send your comments to [email protected] !
Mike king • Apr 19, 2020 at 3:40 pm
Excellent article Rebecca and thank you Professor Shaw for continuing to actively advocate for NVU!
Rebecca Flieder • Apr 19, 2020 at 4:38 pm
Thank you, Mike! Your and the community’s support is what keeps us going.
H. Brooke Paige • Apr 19, 2020 at 3:37 pm
There is worse than a Captain who is willing to scream “ABANDON SHIP” at the sight of an iceberg on the horizon !
Julie Smith • Apr 19, 2020 at 2:29 pm
Get rid of him.. we need these colleges to stay open for the students for the employees for the communities. We need time to regroup and rethink how to salvage these colleges. Breathe new light into how we can get funding support from an outside source to take over and help the colleges to be successful!!!!!!
Edmond Mason • Apr 19, 2020 at 1:40 pm
Why are they just hitting the northeast Kingdom, Castleton has been having trouble for a long time also. Why does UVM get all the money and are untouchable. Do not close the NVU colleges. The Chancellor is a disgrace to this state and needs to be removed immediately !
Melissa Ramsey • Apr 19, 2020 at 1:39 pm
I am a JSC alum and my husband is a VTC Alum. We are completely shocked at the narrow vision shown by Jeb in this moment of grave uncertainty. A true leader would stay the course and explore creative possibilities tirelessly rather then cause further hardship that will effect Vermonters for generations to come. His lack of vision warrants this vote of no confidence and frankly his removal. There is always a way!
Laurie A Mason • Apr 19, 2020 at 1:36 pm
to completely ingore the needs of the NEK is beyond me, those colleges mean so much to the community, students and also the high school students getting ready for college. We need to keep these colleges, students and young people in Vermont. Please do not close NVU colleges.
Ken Whie • Apr 19, 2020 at 1:28 pm
Please let it be clear I am not an Aumnus of LSC. I was a resident of Lyndon.for more than 40 years, I worked as the Advertising Director of the Caledonian-record for 43 years and certainly have some idea of how much of an impact it would have on our communities surrounding. Jeb Spaulding’s idea of a shutdowh of LSC and JSC certainly would be devastating. I do believe as usual they want the one college CSC to have it all on one side of the state. The NEK has always been forgotten to the other side of the state espcially by our State Politicians.
John Fish • Apr 19, 2020 at 1:05 pm
Keep them in Vermont was your cry !
Vermont State College Students deserve better then this!!!!
Really bad decision and worst timing with little respect to students who were just uprooted from the system without refunds, still in classes online until May, and won’t be able to transfer credits at some of these schools. You’ve just paralyzed students and community’s even more! Say the least about the jobs lost.
Here’s an idea why not consolidate the top heavy K-12 district supervisory unions office and superintendents, and fund state colleges. The money being thrown around in this country to the rich is absurd. These schools go away they don’t just come back that easily. The economic engine that these schools trickle down to local economies especially in Northern Vermont is high. Even if you were to make the system solvent again your announcement today just caused a shift in potential enrollment!
Vermont kids deserve better then this shame on you , shame on us!
Taylor Hollis • Apr 19, 2020 at 11:45 am
I am a 3rd year at NVU-Lyndon and Jeb Spaulding needs to be fired immediately! I will be participating in the protest tomorrow afternoon to show my support for NVU-Lyndon. My vote for governor as well as other positions will reflect this.
Cherri McMurray • Apr 19, 2020 at 11:44 am
Never in my life have I seen anything handled this poorly with little, to no regard, of the studehts, their parents and the communities in which these schools are located. The Chancellor is a disgrace to this state and needs to be removed immediately !